Omnivore Alternatives? [SOLVED FOR ME]
from fenndev@leminal.space to selfhosted@lemmy.world on 16 Nov 00:46
https://leminal.space/post/12370036

I’m looking for a self-hosted alternative for Omnivore. To keep it short and sweet, I’m looking for an app that I can subscribe to RSS feeds from and maintain Reader Mode-esque archives of news articles and interesting things I’ve read. Obsidian integration would be nice but is not a priority; however, the ability to save from Android is a must.

Hoarder is something I’ve recently spun up on my home server but despite looking great, it doesn’t do what I’d like it to do. Clicking on an article doesn’t present me with a Reader Mode archive, it takes me to the actual webpage; I have to click on something else to get the cached version (and even then, it doesn’t format things in the way I’d like). I feel this order of operations should be reversed. On the mobile app, you can’t even access the cached version.

I’ve used Wallabag before, but disliked the mobile interface. I wasn’t self-hosting, however, so I’m not sure the difficulty level for it. Barring finding anything better, I’ll likely try and self-host Wallabag.

Shiori looks fantastic but I’d rather not resort to using Termux on my Android phone to share content. No mobile app makes it difficult.

Any suggestions?

SOLVED

Following numerous suggestions, I spun up a FreshRSS container and will be looking into both Shiori (which has a third-party mobile app) and Linkwarden. Thanks, everyone!

#selfhosted

threaded - newest

grimer@lemmy.world on 16 Nov 00:52 next collapse

I’m finding Linkwarden to be pretty helpful

fenndev@leminal.space on 16 Nov 00:54 collapse

I was just looking at this, actually. For a moment I thought it was going to be a bust but then I saw there is a preference option to open the readable form of a page by default. I also love PWAs…

rmstyle@feddit.org on 16 Nov 00:54 next collapse

Maybe Linkwarden? Not reader oriented but it supports it and has an App.

fenndev@leminal.space on 16 Nov 01:00 collapse

Linkwarden doesn’t appear to support RSS, which is a massive bummer.

MMAniacle@lemm.ee on 16 Nov 01:19 next collapse

Not sure if you were aware, you can run a minimal selfhosted Omnivore setup. Not sure if it will meet your needs or not

fenndev@leminal.space on 16 Nov 01:28 collapse

It’s hosted, but not self-hosted.

MMAniacle@lemm.ee on 16 Nov 01:32 next collapse

So the title of the blog post is incorrect? I didn’t look at it super closely so apologies if I’m incorrect

asap@lemmy.world on 16 Nov 09:18 collapse

The “minimal” part is incorrect; it is a super complicated container. The number of moving parts don’t leave me with any confidence that I could keep it running or fix any issues going forwards.

MMAniacle@lemm.ee on 16 Nov 19:34 collapse

Totally agree there, I’m only aware it exists because I didn’t want to go through the hassle of setting up/maintaining either.

I assume “minimal” refers more to the fact that it won’t have all Omnivore features rather than it being uncomplicated to set up

rumba@lemmy.zip on 16 Nov 01:36 next collapse

The directions specifically lead through using a docker host and an elastic search host, But there’s certainly no reason you couldn’t just do that on your own.

interurbain1er@sh.itjust.works on 16 Nov 03:11 collapse

By curiosity, what are you trying to say ?

JustMarkov@lemmy.ml on 16 Nov 10:09 next collapse

No mobile app makes it difficult.

Shiori has a 3rd party mobile client.

tutus@sh.itjust.works on 16 Nov 10:58 next collapse

I settled on Raindrop.io which is free but I paid to support it ($30 a year I think). I had to change my workflow slightly and the Obsidian integration is not as great as Omnivore’s, but it wasn’t a pain. The browser integration is really good and I prefer it to Omnivore’s. It supports RSS and has a decent mobile app.

Overall I think it’s a decent replacement and I’m happy.

I tried Wallabag but the Obsidian integration was poor and Wallabag felt unloved recycle by extension made me question it’s future (which is unfair given my limited time with it). There was a trial which was not enough time for me to evaluate it comfortably.

pe1uca@lemmy.pe1uca.dev on 16 Nov 13:26 next collapse

Maybe FreshRSS with some extensions?
I saw a recent commit to fire an event when saving a favorite, so probably you can get an extension to send the link to something like archivebox for the pages you favorite.

I’ve just fiddled with an already created extension, but they seem fairly simple to create your own easily.
Of course you can inject JS so you could make it more complex if you want.

Sujan@lemmy.ml on 16 Nov 13:46 next collapse

I have started downloading websites as markdown files and then syncing them with syncthing.

schmurian@lsmu.schmurian.xyz on 16 Nov 18:32 collapse

What are you using to download them as Markdown?

bluegandalf@lemmy.ml on 16 Nov 14:30 next collapse

Take a look at Linkding. Run the latest-plus version to archive pages and get reader mode features. You can use Linkdy as the Android app for it. I’m unsure about the RSS features though.

I think a separate FreshRSS container would be better for that though, and you can use ReadYou as the Android app.

damnthefilibuster@lemmy.world on 16 Nov 19:35 collapse

I agree with others that you need to break down these requirements into multiple apps. I use FreshRSS for feeds and it has a bunch of mobile app integrations.

And the most recent update of Linkwarden seems to have a ton of features that might be worth your while, including PDF, screenshot, and Readable caching.

linuxiac.com/linkwarden-2-8-bookmark-manager/

fenndev@leminal.space on 17 Nov 02:46 collapse

I just spun up a FreshRSS container and it is working flawlessly for that purpose so far. I appreciate the suggestions.